Strength Tanks

[Uhm]

Hmm, I admit comparing two different dungeons makes it a little invalid. But I stand with my point that I've never met a good strength tank before, meaning that I don't like the thought of not so high level people (like myself) running around like that. The only time I had a similar experiance was with a really undergeared tank (The Vault).
With "easier to heal" I'm not talking about keeping them at full health at all times it's just esier to predict the damage, and only when I can predict that the tank doesn't die in the next 3 seconds can I dps as well, which is nice.
I actually don't see many strength tanks though, it would be cool to get one that makes me go "Well, that was a fun run!" some day. With tanks that have mostly Vit stuff I just assume they have their points in strength. At least that's what I do.
I find it funny that people get so defensive about this, all three things are possible and this is really just an "my opinion is the only one that matters" discussion.

[Jamillion]

snip

No, it's simple math really, considering equal skill, class and relevant gear 25% more tank DPS will always be a bigger contribution than the one heal buffer provided by fending. Stop using your own admittedly invalid experiences to argue against simple fact.

[Uhm]

No, it's simple math really, considering equal skill, class and relevant gear 25% more tank DPS will always be a bigger contribution than the one heal buffer provided by fending. Stop using your own admittedly invalid experiences to argue against simple fact.

Meh, if I don't make my mistakes openly here where people can correct me if they please I don't learn. I'd rather make mistakes and admit to them than believing that everything I say is a 100% fact. All I'm saying is I like that heal buffer cause I don't see tanks often who actually use their cooldowns correctly.

Should i call every single VIT player bad now?

I never called every Str tank bad if thats what you wanted to bring across with that. I even said I would be happy to get a good one some day, I just never did up until now. I had a ton of bad Vit ones too but I actually don't see many tanks loosing hate lately and if they do then again it's mostly skill if they are not outgeared.