S|E,
You did an amazing job by putting Yoshi-P in place. We are grateful that out 80$ Collectors Edition purchase made the game worth fixing. And, we respect that the game is going to need to be buried, for financial reasons, if we don't start paying for it.
But as you know, the game is not yet worth paying for. It's a fun experience, and even enriching in spots. But the core game is still at a level lower than that of any other AAA MMO currently on the market. Additionally, there are several competing titles which are slated for launch in Q4 2011 and Q2 2012 which will substantially lower the player base of the core game.
Combined with the larger percentage who won't be willing to pay for the game in its current state, only to have the world and content they worked so hard for 'Upgraded out of Existence', I recommend the following:
Allow players who have reached a certain level within the game (... say... 20) to purchase a lifetime subscription to the game. It will allow a much higher initial stimulus then your current expectations, and, allow players to feel like their investment in the game is warranted.
If a player knows that they will be able to play FFXIV-2 for one reasonable flat price, they will fee rewarded in investing in the game yet again (before it is repaired/upgraded to a true AAA experience).
Though I can not venture to guess what a reasonable Dollar amount is, I offer the following:
An escelating deal:
October 2011 - January 2012 - 80.00USD
February 2012 - July 2012 - 140.00 USD
August 2012 - 2.0 Launch 2012 - 180.00 USD
Forever On - 250.00 USD
With this structure, the players are given access to a reasonable lifetime structure which helps them to ignore being slated to pay for an unfinished product, while staying with a game that has yet to reach its potential, despite the fact that there are other AAA titles to play. Additionally, having a lifetime account with a game has proven to bring players back to a game they own despite it not being their #1 time consuming MMO.
I offer this suggestion knowing, that I will be among those who pay for play in the new structure, but offering that this premature reinstatement is bad for the morale of a game which has suffered for the last 12 months.
As always, thank you for attempting to bring the brand into the new era of gaming. We are grateful for where the game is headed. 14 months to get this content is just a wee bit daunting. To be asked to pay 200 USD in monthly fees to get there is a bit daunting.
Professor Cid
Conjurer of Trabia