Make it a base class going from Samurai to Shogun, and Ronin. One would be tank, the other would be dps. A lot of people want Samurai to be tank, and a lot of people want it to be DPS. I think it would do well as both! Maybe the Shogun could lean towards honor and glory, while the Ronin struggle with being completely independent. In my eyes there's more than just one type of Samurai, and i'd like to see FFXIV explore that. Maybe the Ronin are more supportive of Ala Mhigans, and maybe the Shogun are more supportive of saving Othard. The possibilities are endless. Think about it.