Are my mitigation numbers off ?

[Freyyy]

Using Vengeance out of the blue to get a stack back is far from practical, thus that leaves only Berserk.

Bro do you even Raw Intuition ?

Edit:

Oh and,

Now you're throwing in raid based damage as well? In that case, you're forgetting about Divine Veil here. And conveniently enough, the mechanics in that particular encounter makes groups stack up for a lot of things

Unless you're bringing a MNK in your group, Divine Veil doesn't even nearly compensates the lack of Delirium and Reprisal. Divine Veil's CD is the big problem. In Thordan EX, the only moment where Divine Veil is better is for the boss's LB since it's untargettable. But with Deployment Tactics, having Divine Veil or not doesn't make any difference. You'll just let Medica II tick for longer before having people back at 100%, thus leading into less overheal anyway. The only true advantage of PLD over DRK on Thordan EX is Sheltron for Heels and cleaves, and Clemency during Holy Bladedance since it doesn't cancel the cast. It's better selfish mitigation at the cost of raid-wide mitigation.