Current state of MCH?

[Underdog2204]

If MCH was going to compete with BRD for a spot, they'd need to be able to fill in the same niche and become interchangable. They already shot themselves in the leg back in 2.0 when they made BRD the only job capable of giving other players tp/mp regen, whihc may or may not be necessary for the content at hand. The other was not make any jobs have it, and that BRD/MCH is interchangable with both casters in regards of a ranged dps.

I agree, it's like giving raid bosses a debuff that only a certain dps job can dispel and calling it supporting.

Such a class would still be necessary and it's counterparts would need that dispel too, doesn't make it a great idea though. This is the BRD and MCH position atm, it's just their button is this dispel disguised as a regen.

I agree with you on their homogenization for sure, the line between them is so wonky it might aswell be called a squiggle.