
The first sign of not being able to articulate yourself properly is to start slinging mud at whom you argue against. Instead of a mindless dribble I have to read about how subjugated the astro is against our superior overlords someone tell me what makes the white mage so much stronger then the astro.
Stop being stupid and ill gladly lay off.
Last edited by Vlady; 11-14-2015 at 07:11 AM.

And no I don't care if not a single person agrees with me. I do care about people's view who puts out a well thought out proposal and not a knee jerk reaction that is not merited. Last thing I want to see is one job overwhelmingly cause other two to be benched. The astrologian blows the white mage away on healing now because for some wierd reason the astro had to be as good at healing as the white mage and now people want the same treatment for competing with scholars..
Last edited by Vlady; 11-14-2015 at 07:36 AM.


Not at all, I back everything up and don't let my own bias get the better of me, I don't speak in opinions, I speak in facts and generally accepted statements. This is the exact opposite of vlady who is so biased that he thought astro was just as good if not a better healer than the other two before it even got buffed, which is highly laughable.
I've made it very clear on multiple accounts that Astro is my favorite healer to play, but the flaws it has are so obvious I get baffled anytime someone is blind to them. I bring these to light because I want them to be fixed, how can people not understand that? I want Astro to be the best healer, but it ain't gonna happen for awhile by the looks of it. The kit is just too restricted.
I do give people too much credit though I suppose. Should be obvious a class with nearly dozen more healing abilities and healing related cooldowns would be better at throughput.
Don't spread such rubbish about me when you clearly don't know anything about me or my posting history, thx.
Last edited by FoxyAreku; 11-16-2015 at 08:55 AM.

I do suppose that you're speaking about the DPS toolkit...
Because in term of healing the toolkit is fine. You can deal with all the situation with all the spell you have. Plus if good rng your card will ease it up even more.
...
By the way, you said that a class that have a dozen more heal or healing CD is better...
With this statement
Whm is first with one more ability than AST
Ast is second because SCH is last with nearly no healing spell beside physic and adlo
It's not how many spell or great CD you have that make a good heal... It's how they are used and fit the situation
Sorry nothing is obvious
And the AST after boost is on par with the other, no more no less
Well, Whm has assize, it's great, it can heal or Damage. But remember that Ast got a mana reduction on his healing spell (except for Aspected benefic that cost more). 353 mana for "Benefic" vs"442" for cure (ex. You can see that all the spell got lower mana. Gravity is cheaper tooWHM still has a slight advantage over AST with the current meta of one solo healer + one SCH. WHM has slightly more of a throughput in terms of healing with divine seal (lower cooldown and higher healing increase than synystry) and 3 oGCD heals, one which is aoe and restores mana as well. However, AST brings buffs to the party that WHM doesn't, which are tied to a little too much RNG still. Currently in savage WHM edges AST out due to the healing requirements with solo heal + SCH. This may all change with the next raid patch.
And about Synastry, you maybe get an 10 % less increase than ds but the spell is stronger than Divine seal. 40% of original spell within 20 sec for the one that got synastry. You can't beat that.
Whm is easier to play when you get content with heavy aoe.
A1s, Medica2 and his range. Medica II is enough to keep everybody alive.
a3s, Medica2, asylum, Assyze, Cure III. So it's much easier than Ast. Unless if you lack of dps, Ast can help.
But for A2s. No aoe, in term of healing, you can really shine with ast. Synastry is strong and he allows you to solo heal with ease.
Use gravity on the guys with the highest Hp, cause if he die before the cast, you lost the spell
Last edited by NamoNanamo; 11-15-2015 at 12:11 AM.



Yeah synastry really shines in single target/double target healing. I love the fact they changed the old version of synastry, which was very very weak, to this version.Well, Whm has assize, it's great, it can heal or Damage. But remember that Ast got a mana reduction on his healing spell (except for Aspected benefic that cost more). 353 mana for "Benefic" vs"442" for cure (ex. You can see that all the spell got lower mana. Gravity is cheaper too
And about Synastry, you maybe get an 10 % less increase than ds but the spell is stronger than Divine seal. 40% of original spell within 20 sec for the one that got synastry. You can't beat that.
Whm is easier to play when you get content with heavy aoe.
A1s, Medica2 and his range. Medica II is enough to keep everybody alive.
a3s, Medica2, asylum, Assyze, Cure III. So it's much easier than Ast. Unless if you lack of dps, Ast can help.
But for A2s. No aoe, in term of healing, you can really shine with ast. Synastry is strong and he allows you to solo heal with ease.
With a2s i think whm vs ast is all down to group preferance more than anything now. AST can bring some useful healing cooldowns and gravity, whilst whm can bring more dps in the earlier waves.
Kind of makes you wonder if in the next raid tier they make healing checks slightly lower will the meta change firmly to sch/ast as raid healers?
But anyway, i fear we are derailing the original topic a little.

Lol love all the hate nocturnal sect is getting. I have watched an astro solo heal ravana ex in nocturnal. I can't do it personally, but I'm trying to get better with it. Personally nocturnal to me is fun as shit. And very helpful. But yes, you do more overall healing in diurnal.

I dun think nocturnal sect is really getting any hate. If your group has the mechanics down ravana extreme could probably be solo healed by an astro without even being in any sect. The issue is the astrologian is a sort of wierd hybrid that is on par with white mage now but shift into nocturnal does not really work well to replace the scholar.. I hope they will turn nocturnal into a unique offensive buff for astro with a unique shield mechanic over just trying to copy/paste parts of the scholar since they did buff potencies for duirnal stance.Lol love all the hate nocturnal sect is getting. I have watched an astro solo heal ravana ex in nocturnal. I can't do it personally, but I'm trying to get better with it. Personally nocturnal to me is fun as shit. And very helpful. But yes, you do more overall healing in diurnal.
The gimmick does not work well either when you can job change to white mage or scholar which makes a hybrid healer of both healer roles a bit forced.
|
|
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
|
Cookie Policy
This website uses cookies. If you do not wish us to set cookies on your device, please do not use the website. Please read the Square Enix cookies policy for more information. Your use of the website is also subject to the terms in the Square Enix website terms of use and privacy policy and by using the website you are accepting those terms. The Square Enix terms of use, privacy policy and cookies policy can also be found through links at the bottom of the page.

Reply With Quote


