MCH..The dying breed?

[Velhart]

Not unless their damage was balanced around it, as much as drg and mnk are.
And if they did that, hyper charge on average still wouldn't be comparable to the boost from foe.

Then the blunt/slash/piercing debuff should be removed entirely and just base potency around what it would be with it on. On all jobs, not just ranged DPS. Imagine MCH getting that move, then you have BRD that is balanced to compete with MCH that utilizes the debuff, now getting an advantage of higher DPS. Unless someone gives me a good reason why the debuffs have to stay, they seem more like a crutch than a utility.