Had an interesting mentor roulette today.
Que up, go in and it's the Aery. Not a fan of that dungeon but oh well. First pull I grab the first two dragons (I'm on PLD) and run to the wall grabbing the other 3 mobs. Everything seems to be going fine, dps seems about right as mobs are dying at a steady pace. Then it happens. My hp steadily falls to 50% and keeps going down, down more, down even further until I'm at 10% at which I'm like okay where are the heals. Then i die right before the last 2 mobs die. The healer is a sprout so I give the benefit of the doubt.
Next wall pull almost the same thing except this time when I start noticing lack of heals I pop HG to avoid dying and having to run back again. Pull the first boss and this healer (WHM) is STRUGGLING bad. And I mean BAD. Spamming cure 2s and medica, going oom, not dpsing (not the biggest deal but w.e). Yet we manage to down the boss. I inspect the WHM after the boss dies and his gear is mostly level appropriate but I shit you not this guy was using a lv42 wand and shield for weapons.
I advised him to invest in a staff because that's why hes struggling so bad (his cure 2s would heal for maybe 5% of my hp) and hes cool about it and says thanks. But JEEZE man. Hall of the Novice needs to do a better job at informing new players or wand/shield needs to be removed from the game entirely for WHM since it's just old useless garbo from 1.0-2.0 that was just simply never removed.
We still cleared the dungeon in good speed because I wasn't about to not do wall to wall pulls. And the fact that he was able to keep up for the most part tells me that the guy will at least be a decent healer once he gets his hands on an appropriate weapon. Just sucks no staff dropped at all in the run for him, it could have changed his life lol.