Quote Originally Posted by MeeYow View Post
You missed the point, AoE encounters cannot justify infinite TP in single target encounters
They don't have "infinite TP." They have as much TP as melee DPS do throughout an encouter, at least MNK and DRG, which all tanks should have.

Quote Originally Posted by MeeYow View Post
Eviscerate vs Dark passenger easily gives WAR the edge and any good WAR will drop two off right when the group pops
Yes. "Eviscerate" is better than Dark Passenger, but that's how WAR is designed. They're suppose to have the best AoE DPS out of all the tanks; regardless, DRK is always right on the heels on WAR in terms of DPS in A2S because DRK AoE DPS is more sustainable due to Blood Price; which, brings us to our next point.

Quote Originally Posted by MeeYow View Post
Furthermore DRK has to maintain their MP through combos whereas equilibrium is free TP.
It seems you're forgetting about Blood Price which is 10 seconds of MP regen on a 40 second cooldown. In AoE pulls that gives DRK nearly infinite MP while it's up.

You know, for someone acting as an authority on how to balance tanks you sure don't know a thing about them, but what do I know? "Eviscerate" and "overwhelm" are just too powerful. WAR needs those nerfs.