i got a question for you dps..

[Jim_Berry]

Yes, tanks have a secondary job to do as much dps as they can, but this job is codified as: "Tanks should dish out as much dps as they can while maintaining enmity on all targets they are tasked with holding." The bolded part is called your main job. If you can't do that, stop trying to do more dps. That's basically it. That's the whole discussion.

I maintain enmity but suck at dps'ing on my tank. What does that say about me, then? I'm a crappy tank, or a tank that's good at being a tank? And yes, I only do VIT gear, and stay in tank stance because of being a tank, yo.

Every tank has options to enhance their enmity generation. You just have to actually use them. And use them properly.
The messed up part is, when a tank is using his/her enmity generation properly, they get a thumbs down for not excelling at doing damage. I really don't understand the community anymore.

Note my bolded comments.