I liked Revenant's Toll more than Idyllshire

[CGMidlander]

It was more spacious, had better music IMO, mounts were allowed there, and it changed over time.

[SasukeUchiha81]

I agree 100%.. It really was a much better area to chill at for our high levels. :/

[myahele]

I'm sure Idyllshire will change every other major patch. But yeah I'm not liking that it's instanced since those multiple idyllshire quests were so annoying

[Magistrella]

I'm sure Idyllshire will change every other major patch. But yeah I'm not liking that it's instanced since those multiple idyllshire quests were so annoying

Yoshi already said they were usually planning to leave Idyllshire in Hinterlands but they didn't want to face the same problems for Hinterlands as Revenant's Toll did for Mor Dhona

He also said they know that it is a problem to get out of Idyllshire quick and move around in it because you could fly in(to) it at first and that they are working on a solution

@OP:

If i look at the size - Revenant's Toll is smaller
Music is subjective - i like the Idyllshire one better
Mounts - read above
Changing over time - how should it change overtime if we aren't even yet in 3.1+? >.>

[Fevelle]

He also said they know that it is a problem to get out of Idyllshire quick

The Goodly Adventurer NPC takes you direct to Hinterlands, there's not even any dialog. It's even quicker than summoning a mount if that was the case.

[Velox]

I'm sure Idyllshire will change every other major patch. But yeah I'm not liking that it's instanced since those multiple idyllshire quests were so annoying

It has to be instanced though. Revenant Toll could only be developed so much to a point where any more models and you'd start to tax low-end systems like the ps3. By instancing Idyllshire, not only do you make it load-heavy when a lot of people are there buy if they choose to expand off of it they aren't restricted as much in size. Afterall, Ul'dah is instanced for a reason and not just a part of Thanalan.

[Erendis]

It also sucks that Hinterlands is the only zone that does not have a sanctuary...

[Colorful]

I dislike them both, I wish they'd just add the vendors to Ishgard. The daytime music in Idyllshire drives me insane, not to mention the people who keep spamming loud abilities. >_< Ishgard also has my favourite OST from this expansion so far.

[Felis]

It was more spacious, had better music IMO, mounts were allowed there, and it changed over time.

Give the Goblins time to rebuild it.
Even Revenant's Tolls was at the beginning just a handfull tents.

[fortuona]

no incentive to hang out in ishgard after the story ends kind of sucks. idyllshire is a dump.