"Show me who a person's friends are, and I will tell you who that person is."
Pro tip. Don't trust everything you read on here about required stat caps. I have both the dip 210 and the Gordian spear. 2.39 GCD versus 2.41... I have no problem performing exactly the same rotation with 2.41 gcd. Furthermore, no transition periods in savage were handled any differently because my gcd went up to 2.41. I can tell you with the certainty of well over 100 trials with baked pira pira on that Gordian spear is roughly a 40 to 50 dps increase over the dip spear, despite having under 590 SS. My ss is currently 576, 481 det 821 crit, 624 accuracy, no food, 1079 str. DIP spear rotation 1460's after 3:30 on dummy, Gordian 1500+ ever time, crit jump or no crit jump opener beyond 3:30 and far fewer tp problems.. problems which you are going to have with higher SS in A4S for sure. I am constantly tp starved in A4S final phase, no matter how I use invigorate. Our warrior is getting the nin goad for sprint royal pent purposes.
It's because of your ~Determination~ that you see far more consistent and consistently higher results. Building for Crit with low Det noticeably decreases the floor value for your damage. It raises the mean, sure, letting you see higher (on average), but parse-to-parse, a det/crit build (rather than a pure-crit build) is gonna obviously see consistently higher results, because the damage floor is drastically raised.
And I think it was stated before (with numbers) by another guy that sks beyond 600 was pretty much worthless and resulted in overall loss of DPS. I'd have to dig for his post outlining this, but it's there.
I've been at 2.4 the longest time and can vouch for this and starting to believe that latency plays more a role along with fight-to-fight basis rotations.
Last edited by Gaiussenpai; 12-24-2015 at 12:12 PM. Reason: I can't quote
Definitely. I can't dip below 590 ss since i play on a 250 ms connection. I can still get 3 geirskoguls a minute with 605 ss but it's very unforgiving. One more month and I'll be back in the states to try out the gordian spear!
I think there's something consistently flawed with your testing. >2% DPS increase is preposterous; that's in the realm of a weapon damage upgrade, not a sidegrade.I can tell you with the certainty of well over 100 trials with baked pira pira on that Gordian spear is roughly a 40 to 50 dps increase over the dip spear, despite having under 590 SS. My ss is currently 576, 481 det 821 crit, 624 accuracy, no food, 1079 str. DIP spear rotation 1460's after 3:30 on dummy, Gordian 1500+ ever time, crit jump or no crit jump opener beyond 3:30 and far fewer tp problems.. problems which you are going to have with higher SS in A4S for sure. I am constantly tp starved in A4S final phase, no matter how I use invigorate. Our warrior is getting the nin goad for sprint royal pent purposes.
٩( ʘᆺʘ )۶ Qiqirns never skip egg day!
Stat spread:
Brionac:
102 Crit / 71 Sks
Gordian Trident:
97 Det / 71 Crit
If you change nothing aside from the weapon and do a parse on a dummy without having a defined time that you will cut the parse (as was done in the test), you're literally comparing 102 crit to 97 det and 71 crit, since sks has a negligible impact on your dps (yay dot tick boost?) outside of letting you connect with more hits in a shorter timeframe.
So yeah, you'll see a huge boost in damage when adding 97 det to the parse. That's effectively 13 additional strength, which is more than +1 weapon damage.
Comparatively, upgrading from Brionac to Halberd of the Heavens saw my dps jump 60-70 on standstill dummy parses, due to the drastically improved stat spread that the Heaven spear afforded me (in addition to +1 wd).
But the difference per hit between Brionac and Gordian Trident is ~1.3% (not formula guesses; tested in-game damage). The skill speed and crit pretty much make up that difference, on average.
٩( ʘᆺʘ )۶ Qiqirns never skip egg day!
Makes sense since 100 det ~ 1% damage boost, need master Dervy to weight in
Going single target, Gordian Trident should beat Brionac by <1 DPS and relic by ~1 DPS (on average). Pretty tiny difference, other than TP usage.
٩( ʘᆺʘ )۶ Qiqirns never skip egg day!
|
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
Cookie Policy
This website uses cookies. If you do not wish us to set cookies on your device, please do not use the website. Please read the Square Enix cookies policy for more information. Your use of the website is also subject to the terms in the Square Enix website terms of use and privacy policy and by using the website you are accepting those terms. The Square Enix terms of use, privacy policy and cookies policy can also be found through links at the bottom of the page.