Sorry, but no tank should pure vit stack right side.

[Syzygian]

Towards the end of ARR. Tanks were making some awesome crafted STR/VIT accessories melded with STR/VIT to help their raid push out extra dps while not being any less tanky. Now that HW is here, we see the devs intentionally not offering any i180 combat accessories, because we were bending gameplay and their raid design.

Hilariously enough, the regular i150 accessories will still meld to more STR and VIT combined than any combination of i210 fending/slaying gear. I personally have two i210 fending pieces, and if I equip those and three i190 slaying pieces as well, I have less STR and VIT than a full set of i150 pentamelds.

You'll have trouble with AS3 DPS checks if you don't swap to Sword Oath as MT whenever you can. Shield Oath PLD DPS is so shitty right now.
And against a dungeon boss, a STR PLD shouldn't lose enmity even with a good DPS while tanking in SwO.
You're most likely a bad tank who doesn't even want to bother trying to actually maximize its efficiency as a job. Or maybe you just don't know what you're talking about.

This made me laugh, you funny.

These posts and the posts they're responding to are all completely dependent on the gear the tank is wearing. A full vit PLD will most likely not be able to keep enmity off skilled DPS in Sword Oath, unless they are spamming Halone and ignoring their other combos that deal more damage, and even then only maybe. A crit Fire IV or a DRG's opener is about all it'd take. Its just funny watching people respond like this as if everyone is wearing the same gear. Everyone isn't.