Harsher Leaver Punishments

[Kemosobe]

Not sure why so many people join dungeons simply to leave 1 sec in, but I see it way too much, and have been seeing it since 2.0. There really needs to be harsher punishments for consecutive dungeon abandonment.

Something I was thinking is to give characters an invisible "Leaver Counter" (or something like that) which increases each time you leave a dungeon before it is completed. And the more "stacks" you have, the harsher the punishments become. Starting at 30 minutes, as it is now, and just increases the more "stacks" you have from leaving. And because people could simply do nothing or "disconnect" and wait to be kicked so they don't get punished for it, being kicked could always give half a "stack", 0.5 instead of 1, but not give an instant punishment unless they have a certain amount of "stacks". And the "counter" would only go down while you are logged in, and at a SUPER slow rate, and get entirely wiped each week.

[Subucnimorning]

No thanks.

If a group is not fun because of how bad it is I think 30 minutes is an acceptable penalty for that.

[Risvertasashi]

So you want to have more people force disconnects instead?

[Mykll]

No thanks.

If a group is not fun because of how bad it is I think 30 minutes is an acceptable penalty for that.

People leaving as soon as they enter a dungeon, have no clue how good or bad the party is yet. They just hate the dungeon they were given in the Roulette.

Simple fix. Enter Roulette, you are stuck with that dungeon and will only ever get that dungeon on future Roulettes, until you complete it.

For people wanting to leave because of a perceived bad group, whether or not they are correct, they are going to leave or simply DC. Not much that can be done without opening up something else that can be abused.

[Vidu]

Let them just lose the bonus if they leave within the first 10 minutes of the dungeon - if they dont like the roulette, give them no reason to do it. 10 minutes is a fair amount of giving even a "bad" group a chance - and if they dont like the dungeon 10 minutes will enough to progress enough so leaving will become less attractive.

Just giving them the same dungeon over and over wont solve the problem... I recall the days where people would leave brayflox HM because they wanted to run it with a blm only...

[Kemosobe]

Let them just lose the bonus if they leave within the first 10 minutes of the dungeon - if they dont like the roulette, give them no reason to do it. 10 minutes is a fair amount of giving even a "bad" group a chance - and if they dont like the dungeon 10 minutes will enough to progress enough so leaving will become less attractive.

That would actually be a decent change. I really just want SOMETHING more than a 30 minute "You can't use the Duty Finder" cooldown because it obviously doesn't work. And ya, I remember back in 2.0 when people would leave when Cutter's Cry was the dungeon. People do it for anything. If I only say it maybe once a week, I wouldn't care as much. But seeing it almost once a day, sometimes 2 or more if I am dungeon running that day, is just getting stupid. And it is almost always either the tank or healer. Insta-queuing and insta-leaving.

[Kaiser-Ace]

I like Vidu's idea best.

Ten menutes is the time it takes to initiate a vote abandon so when the Vote abandon timer is up they could leave and just eat the 30m penalty while getting anouther shot at tge bonus but nix their bonus if they're just like "Up, Darkhold, I'm out". and leave before even the 1st pull.

But vote dismissing a player shouldn't penalize the dismissie, the vote dismiss is already abused bad enough as is.

[Mykll]

Just giving them the same dungeon over and over wont solve the problem... I recall the days where people would leave brayflox HM because they wanted to run it with a blm only...

There is a little difference. BF HM they WANTED to run the dungeon, but ONLY as fast as possible to get as many speed runs as possible in. Gotta get them tomes. They queue up for BF HM specifically.

People that leave immediately, are purely now leaving because of the dungeon they got via roulette, regardless of who else is in the party, rather class, job, level, ilvl, or anything else.

[MXMoondoggie]

I don't really think more needs to be done it would just make things worse because people don't want to be there so they will be a pain for however long they are forced to be in there. Better to just let people leave and eat a 30 minute penalty. You still get the obnoxious idiots who fake a DC to try to get kicked and there isn't much you can do without also punishing people who legit DC when it';s not their fault.

[Misutoraru]

it does need harder punishment
but like Vidu said
it is a good idea rather than increasing the DF ban time
if anyone dont like certain dungeon,
then dont do daily roulette
please dont waste other ppl time hoping and waiting for someone Join in progress or re-queue
anyone who leave before the abandon timer should be punish harder