The Real Problem with Parsers

[Archaell]

You may not want to accept it, but if both DPS are pulling 300 DPS and you're still clearing the content, then they're doing acceptable DPS for the content. Objectively. You may subjectively want them to do more, but the game objectively decides what's acceptable.

What happens when you get tank or healer in the group who do the same amount of work as the 300 DPS players? I am quite certain that somebody has to explain why they can't keep up the enmity or tank alive.

The problem comes in when people have different ideas of what's acceptable. Expert roulette only requires an ilvl of 145. That means it's expected to be cleared with i145 gear-sized DPS.

Are you suggesting that everyone in the game will know an OBJECTIVE "acceptable" DPS level based on the gear requirements and accept to put out a minimum of that amount, and conversely accept that anyone putting out at least that minimal amount is being acceptable for the dungeon? But where is this magic objective number going to come from?

Suddenly SE has to come up with a new set of rules and new calculations in order to quantify what levels of DPS are acceptable that they can put on the DF listing so you know not to go if you don't qualify, or else you can be kicked "in fairness".

This magic number is going to come from... players playing the game. If you see DPS player doing 1000 dps and similarly geared another player who is doing 300 DPS, it isn't too hard to tell who is and who isn't putting in enough effort.

That doesn't answer my question. My question was, would it be fine if people kicked tanks for pulling a single group at a time because that was what they were comfortable with? For that matter, are you fine with people kicking tanks because they stay in tank stance instead of switching to DPS stance to make the run faster, simply because they're not comfortable removing their tankiness or not comfortable with their threat generation?

Are you fine with people kicking healers for solely healing instead of stance dancing because they're not comfortable with it and don't want to risk a wipe because they didn't do it right?

Yes, I am okay with it. If the group can't stand small pulls, tank stanced tank or healer who doesn't want to dps then they are free to kick them. Clearly these guys deserve to wait for a new tank/healer, while the tank/healer gets a new reasonable group in matter of seconds.