You called people who kick an underperforming dps "selfish" for wasting everyones time many many times throughout those first 15 pages. Your quite apparent lack of ability to understand the word selfish is what made me quit reading, you want a strawman argument go back and look at all your posts.

Your first argument being that EVERYONE who has poor dps will be kicked, this has been refuted multiple times by people. Basically the general consensus is that first you try to talk to the player, then you give it a shot anyways, then if they still haven't started putting in effort you kick. Again this is the same as if your tank or healer perform poorly, you try a couple times but if nothing gets fixed you kick them.

Then you say that anyone who kicks someone for having poor dps is a selfish player, meanwhile the majority of people will try to help those players out first. The player who refuses to take any help or advice (pretty much anyone you call out on doing bad dps) and instead wastes multiple peoples time, day in and day out week after week is the more selfish person, do we need a dictionary definition for you here or will you accept the fallacy of your "selfish" statements yet?

I even stated in my post about the qarn/sastasha hm fights that I tried, tried to do the fight a few times, tried to give rotation advice, tried the fight again, but the player refuses to get better and more often than not is very rude and offensive for even being called out in the first place no matter how polite you are about it.

Again I ask you, if your tank or healer was performing absolutely abysmally to the point where the run is going to take 10-15 extra minutes and require a ton of extra work on the part of everyone else, WOULD YOU KICK THEM??