Quote Originally Posted by Amberyl View Post
Because Square do. It's a huge part of how and why they write the way they write.
That's fine, it is up to them.

But we are talking about is the other players shooting down the idea. Practically calling the players who want to be evil, evil in real life.

We could go back and forth with all kinds of things, but until the story is entirely fleshed out you can't call anyone good or bad.