You're advocating for the wrong kind of player to be rocking str accessories. Bad tanks have no need for str accessories, they aren't at a level of play that encourages deviation from the norm. If a tank is making multiple mistakes, I'd much rather them have a bigger cushion.

Quote Originally Posted by Nektulos-Tuor View Post
Vitality does not increase your survivability, it increases your "own" chance to make mistakes. Its a very "SELFISH" stat.
In this sense, vit does increase your survivability, as a tank that isn't confident in their abilities or knows they make mistakes can stack vit to give the healer a cushion. Stacking str will only reduce their margin for error, which, according to you,

Quote Originally Posted by Nektulos-Tuor View Post
Vitality tanks are lazy and usually go through threat rotations more because they have to to even hold aggro. They usually make mistakes, a lot of them and seem afkish and yell at you when they pull 3-4 rooms and it takes 2 minutes to kill then whine when they die.
error is an all too common occurrence as a vit tank. You should let tanks make mistakes when it is most lenient on them, when they have more HP.

Quote Originally Posted by Nektulos-Tuor View Post
Vitality is pretty much "Training Wheels", once you know how to ride your bike (tank good) take them off. All your doing is making the healer's job harder for no reason.
Once they've become comfortable in their role, they can start experimenting how they want. Training wheels are to keep you steady because you're bad or aren't confident, then you learn the basics and try going without.

Quote Originally Posted by Nektulos-Tuor View Post
I don't want Padding or "Training Wheels" I want a tank who doesn't lose aggro to me or the dps and actually contributes more to the fight then a damage sponge.
Then don't pug? If they don't know how to ride without training wheels (tank good) why would they try it without? It's up to you to find like minded players if a tank wearing vitality accessories sends you in a tizzy. Your PSA doesn't reach the intended audience at all since,

Quote Originally Posted by Nektulos-Tuor View Post
as a suggestion to new players
they probably don't know what they're doing, and do indeed benefit from the added cushion, and experienced players that can wear whatever they want are already doing so.