Still none of the needed changes?

[Aiselia]

Except you skipped the main point Disembowl is a raid utility.

No I didn't. I specifically also pointed out that Disembowel is "the same effect" as Dancing Edge for a different damage type, but that DE would always affect the tank(s) and ninja while Disembowel would only affect the DRG and BRD/MCH.

I ignored Disembowel for mostly the fact that each melee DPS gets a debuff that increases their damage type, which means that without considering specific group compositions (a group without a Bard/MCH will not have as many people benefit from Disembowel whereas a group with 3 BRD/MCH will see a bigger increase from Disembowel), those two abilities are, in themselves, equal.

You made one hell of a leap.

What did you expect from a Dragoon, if not big leaps? :P