Thread: *SPOILERS!* A roadmap from 3.1 to 4.0

Originally Posted by Fenral

Sure, there's no rule, and sure, it's a subversion of our expectations, but what does that subversion actually accomplish for the purposes of world cohesiveness and the ongoing narrative?

This whole thing can be solved pretty easily by the "exception proves the rule" argument. Yes, all the Students of Baldesion we've met so far are MSQ relevant, and G'raha isn't, but that just proves that the Students of Baldesion are important to the MSQ unless it becomes apparent they aren't like G'raha. (It's kind of wonky logic, but if you can grasp the concept it's true.) I had to use this in the "Regula is a woman because she has a feminine name" argument. Until otherwise proven, Regula is, in fact, a man despite having a feminine name because nothing else points to that being true; until otherwise proven, G'raha is, in fact, not MSQ relevant because aside from being a Student of Baldesion nothing points to that being true.

As for the whole series of coincidences that lead up to his introduction (escaped the destruction of the Isle of Val, met Allagan clones who told him his destiny and blah blah blah), it's, y'know, fate. If you believe in that. Otherwise it's just a series of (un)fortunate coincidences.

Originally Posted by Cilia

until otherwise proven, G'raha is, in fact, not MSQ relevant because aside from being a Student of Baldesion nothing points to that being true.

Indeed, but by that same logic, "hope" (yes, that) warrants discussing all presented NPCs as part of the same cohesive world, and there really is no harm in mentioning the million +1 ways in which a character that overloaded could become a viable NPC again, even for just another side story. Let's face it, we don't really have too many Students of Baldesion or Allagans to choose from right now, besides the one, and both seem likely to become big movers and shakers in the events to come.

Unei (or was it Doga?) said he has a fate "tied" to that of Allag, but that's not the same as having a fate "decided" by Allag. If he ever does come back, I believe that's the distinction that will be made, since Allag still seems to have quite a bit left to its own fate.

Originally Posted by Sekundessounet

You can hear Regula's voice (at least in French) in the Aetherochemical Research Facility, and it's a male voice.

Go here for the whole discussion on that issue.

Abridged Ver.

For being a woman
+Feminine name

For being a man
+Masculine build
+Masculine voice
+Referred to as "Lord van Hydrus," not "Lady van Hydrus"
+Quest log uses masculine pronouns

The only other things pointing to Regula being a woman are "what if"s, which don't really constitute an argument.

What if isle of Val is actually a flyng island? and that the airship we see, destroyed it and the 3.1 raid is about it ?! mind = blown

jokes aside, im doing this post, not going to edit it, it would be fun if i actually got it right, ive been sayng it on FC as a joke, but , upon reading more about it, it kinda makes sense. *crosses fingers*

Originally Posted by JeniLinsky

Raubahn's Putsch

*re-reads 3x*

"No, they didn-- Aw, they definitely did"

EDIT

Originally Posted by PogueX

i believe the empire will strike back

Aw, c'mon!