Why refusing customization is a fallacy

[Fyce]

@OP: it doesn't matter if the "I don't want you in my group because your spec sucks" is a problem or not.
The main "issue" with specs is that it would require probably between a year or two of work, scrapping completly the current system.

Obviously, they won't do that.

The only way they could to it in a reasonable time frame would be to add a bunch of useless and uninspired passives to give the illusion of choice... and I don't think that's what you or anyone want.
So, I'm sorry but your post is completly useless since it's not doable without investing a lot of time and money while changing the habits of a lot of players (and possibly lose them as a result).

Anyway, if you just want to debate if yes or no a bad spec would make the player unable to be taken in parties or not, go ahead. But just keep in mind that it's all moot since they won't re-redo their game again for that.
If you abolutly love specs, just go find another game at this point, because they'll never come to FFXIV.

[Reynhart]

The main "issue" with specs is that it would require probably between a year or two of work, scrapping completly the current system.

No, the main issue is that it is dismissed because it could create some form of discrimination.

So, in place of specs and exclusive bonus on items, we have strict vertical progression and complete homogenisation of jobs...and it's likely to continue.

[Sandpark]

No, the main issue is that it is dismissed because it could create some form of discrimination.

So, in place of specs and exclusive bonus on items, we have strict vertical progression and complete homogenisation of jobs...and it's likely to continue.

The system doesn't need any work, it is already in place with classes.
Jobs= Specialization=Different from other jobs=job of same type exactly the same
classes=No specialization=No super powered skills= Variety of purpose skills

A class can heal, deal damage, tank, buff, debuff,etc which is no clear role.
A job usually has one or two roles but cannot fill all roles.