Why refusing customization is a fallacy

[Reynhart]

So...you want to give people the opportunity to make bad choices and directly cause other players even more suffering for objectively bad play?

Excuse me, why do you play DRK when half of tank threads claims that WAR is the absolute "best" ?

Caduceus' ever-building damage stacks on both snakes served as a DPS check and soft-enrage.

On you could feed both snake to bring back their stacks...

Conflags were a DPS check. You were putting fireballs in the conflag to increase the time allowed to meet said check.

Killing adds before they reach a death zone is a DPS check.

Rafflesia's honey bees were a DPS check.

Not one of these things were ever "tight".

Rafflesia's Slugs in the final phase were a DPS check.

Using a limit break to kill one slug and letting the tank run around is anything but a "DPS check"

Every example you give for SCoB and FCoB

Indeed, but does that mean that the other mechanics were skipped ?

Every heavensward example

Problem is that all you HW example are only DPS check except maybe the oppressor.