Dev Suggestion: Unrestricting all cross class action

[ThirdChild_ZKI]

A lot of valid points here. . .

I just want access to Second Wind as a MCH. Right now we're the only DPS job that CAN'T heal itself either by native or cross class skill. The only one. BLM can cross class Physick from SMN, DRG, BRD, and NIN can cross class Second Wind from MNK.

Either open up Second Wind to all physical DPS jobs, or give MCH its own.

[Yggberry]

As of now we only have to level classes that SE wants us to, open the gates to all possible abilities (if I'm reading your suggestion right) and you'll have things like everyone to get swiftcast + enhanced raise (not sure if enhanced abilities can be cross classed, but w/e) for battle raising easier... which would present balance issues, along with countless other abilities that may be useful for other Jobs. SE would have to start developing content around this.

I'd much prefer they ditch the cross class system and instead introduce a specialization and talent system, similar to WoW before they revamped it.

I would welcome that, but I think that's too much work for SE to implement. And it isn't a reality for them to do so. However, cross class skills are since DoL/DoH both still retain this ability.

I think you are forgetting something about the current system. It is already balanced out. Sure, in your example, melee can do swift cast + res to res someone, however, for one, they can only do it out of battle. Secondly, each job only have 5 slots for cross class skills. Even if a melee were able to take those two skills, that would mean they will be leaving out 2 more important skills out of their slot. And of course you can't change on the fly during battle, this won't cause a balancing problem. But I hope that they will let DoW use DoM's cross class skills. Because in 1.0, this was not possible. DoW skills belongs to DoW only and vice versa.

Personally I think the current system is very lackluster. The dev team is trying to fit everyone into this mold with little wiggle room. MMORPG strives on progress, freedom, and customization. Most long lasting mmo out there include a vast amount of all three, including RO, MS, WoW, FF11, and so on so forth. What MMO player looks for when they play MMO is to build their character the way they want. But restricting that can only lead to turn offs. I already am seeing friends reaching level 60 without anything to do and eventually shut off their subscription. SE has to realize that no amount of gating will stop a player's progress. And of course, they can't keep up with the player's progress with continuous updates. Their attempts is only going to turn players off.

[Alexander_Dragonfang]

Berserk isn't a cross class skill.

Not with that attitude.

[Eul]

Oh it would be so nice to have fishing skill so I could catch those sahagin and elbst.

It would be nightmare for healer because people gonna spam Flash or any skill of tank that increase enmity.

[Giantbane]

Cleric Stance has the -20% healing still, making the INT-MND swap not so useful. What'd be really nice for that is a reversed cleric stance.

Pretty sure it will still result in a stronger heal given the current MND levels on lvl 60 BLM/SMN.

[Giantbane]

Just as the title suggested, I personally don't think it will unbalance the game if this was release or implemented. For that matter, I feel that this will bring more depth, progression, and customization to our characters.

They probably still need to do some restrictions per job. I'm pretty sure they don't want all DPS having access to IR + BfB + RS.

But on the whole I think this would be a great idea.