I've only been dismissed once that I felt was unfair. Those players were then reported.

Other than that I have kicked people on several occasions for attacking other players personalities and all together being turds. Only to have them pop up in my instance three more times and waste 8 more minutes of everyone's time cussing at people.

I've never kicked anyone for lack of skill or knowledge though. Those people should be taught and directed... not ignored. I'm so excited that this is in place now.