Yoshi P / Dev Team: FAVOR System - Please Fix This BROKEN System

[Rath]

Nobody is saying they're worthless, though? The suggestion is they should cost fewer tokens to acquire, making them more affordable for the people who need them. They already require roundstones instead of ooids, why make them cost more red scrip tokens too? This extra cost devalues roundstones because anyone who can HQ at least 33% of the time is better off buying NQ and selling the failures; they'll save on scrip and make extra gil besides.

The problem is if they lower the scrip cost, then the people that need them will not get them as the price will go up. The crafters that want to be efficient and not "waste" scrips will buy them up.

You dont need to make them HQ, and they are far easier then previous crafts since these materials have 70 durability instead of 40.

Since People like Aeyis say they do not need the HQ, why change it so that the people that do need them will have to pay an exhorbitant cost as we all know everyone will start using them, not just those that "need" them. The only change they should do to the HQ turn-in items is increase their frequency.

Also, who buys failures? I have only ever seen HQ crafted mats sold. NQ may be listed, but they do not sell.

[Aeyis]

The problem is if they lower the scrip cost, then the people that need them will not get them as the price will go up. The crafters that want to be efficient and not "waste" scrips will buy them up. Since People like Aeyis say they do not need the HQ, why change it so that the people that do need them will have to pay an exhorbitant cost as we all know everyone will start using them, not just those that "need" them. The only change they should do to the HQ turn-in items is increase their frequency.

Also, who buys failures? I have only ever seen HQ crafted mats sold. NQ may be listed, but they do not sell.

Who knows? I have yet to see a NQ material on our marketboard, and precious few HQ ones, all of which were retreived rather then sold.

Your logic is still completely a mystery to me. I dont understand how it works.

Since People like Aeyis say they do not need the HQ

I believe I wrote that at their current exchange rate they are not worth purchasing.
A sentiment the JP playerbase much agrees with. It would seem they have less white knights on that side, what do you know.

And I gave you the detailed reasons as to why, which you ignored twice over.

My comparison was to point out the need for HQ materials. Those crafters I targeted and talked through had no issues with recipes they could get HQ mats for. But as soon as you added in sealants and FC3 and such, they needed serious help.

It was a bad comparison. The difficulty of the current 2*s cant be compared to the difficulty of those recipes. In addition most of the materials in current recipes are HQable.

On top of which trying to HQ 3 items with medium rates gives a higher likely return then trying to HQ 1 item with medium high rates.


I see. So I ignored your provocative posts in that thread, yet you still wish to persist with that discussion?

As someone that needs HQ star saphires, how do you then argue that the most expensive syntheses people have access to SE should take away peoples' ability to use HQ materials?

I needed HQ items when my crafts were not fully leveled, let alone fully melded. And unlike you, I always try to argue the perspectives if the kinds of people involved: small time, medium and big time crafters alike.
Most of which have a need for HQ items in the start of an expansion.
That is all I will say on the topic of that dead horse you try to resurrect so you can beat it.

As for the bolded part: Please stop twisting my words and arguments kudasai. It got tiresome many posts ago. Explaining can be a very tiring thing indeed when someone goes out of their way to rephrase and twist your arguments..

I never said anything remotely similar to ''taking away peoples ability to HQ''. Rather the argument was that HQ turn ins should require 1 token as well; since they are already limited by their low rate of obtaining.
Which would actually make it easier for the ''crafters that have a hard time to HQ'' that you currently claim to represent to obtain them.

[Yoshiru]

again with the rng thing..... thats the challenge!!! whats the point of just giving it away?? oh wait thats what ya all want isnt it just hand me the items i paid my sub you owe me?? lmao and this it takes 11 hrs to grind it out?? i did tcm last night in the 75 min for 5 favors and got my 16 items and went on to something else, the game wont be over tomorrow... if it gets grindy take a break for a bit even a few hrs...

again im not tryin to put anyone down and say what a stupid thing you just said just look at the bigger picture here ppl said it was too easy they made it harder however you want to downplay that now everyone is screaming mercy make it easy again

[KariArisu]

oh wait thats what ya all want isnt it just hand me the items i paid my sub you owe me??

I like how you pull this card rather than trying to make an intelligent response.

RNG is not challenging. It's only used to gate content, which is normally fine, but in this situation it's bad. Red scrips are a limited resource. You have to spend 11 hours a week to spend that resource, and more to earn it. Your reward for spending all of this time, is entirely luck based. Earning red scrips requires you to have the gear, stats, etc to obtain or craft an item. That's challenge. Hitting a node and hoping that something pops, that's not challenging, it's just luck.

[ChasteDaily]

What I don't understand about the favor system is why you need separate "buffs" for each zone. Why not just buy a buff and it will work in whatever zone you are in?

It is already confusing because the buff icon is incorrect in some cases. It just seems like yet another level of unneeded complexity. Keep it simple. For 1 gathering token you get 5 buff to use wherever.

I feel like they just made this whole process overly complex for no good reason.

[Yoshiru]

IMO, why make it so easy that everyone has everything right now, and then we all quit til new shit comes out, Altho i do agree a few things need to be tweeked to it, in all the concept is good, yes the rng sucks but why make it so easy that it takes the fun out of it or the challenge, most desperately cried bout the game to easy now ppl it seems are crying its too hard, i for one think its awesome they made the game alot harder, but i already know ppl are gunna comment saying the same thing over and over that its broken, altho i do agree a few tweeks need to be made in all its working how they intended it to work.

[Joronas]

People confuse "challenge" with "grind until your eyes & fingers bleed" a lot on this forum.

There is no "challenge" in this system. It's just a monotonous, ugly, grind that makes your soul hurt. The closest thing this game has to a challenge in gathering are the leves, and even then, only a few of them.

This system doesn't make the game "harder" either. It's just a straight up rng fest. How does that improve anything? Right now, we're at 11 and a bit hours of favor grinding and 5-6 hours of scrip grinding. Maybe down to 4 for the hardcore. Are we going to go down to 8 hours of favor grinding with the next patch? Who knows? That's still an hour a day plus a bit of soul-destroying monotony. Not challenging, not involving, just run in circles emptying nodes in the hopes the RNG doesn't break and give you nothing for your work.

[Joronas]

RNG is not a challenge.

For it to be a challenge, there has to be some meaningful way that a person can influence the outcome. Saying RNG is a challenge is like saying "winning the lottery" is a challenge. In the context of gathering? The only difference is that this gathering eats up your time as well. Even attempting the argument makes your position weaker, and reduces the strength of your future arguments.

There is nothing "hard" about this system. It's a souldestroying grind that added no difficulty. It's EASY. Except you have do it for 11.25 hours a week, in 15 minute blocks. You can't stop at 7.5 minutes, or you lose the buff. You can't pop a duty finder, or you'll lose the buff when the duty finder goes off. You can't stop and type, because you're running from node to node like mad. It's 15 minutes that you can do nothing else. Oh, and on average? You will not get enough items to max out your crafting side. 4 gathering tokens averages 3 crafting tokens of mats.

[Yoshiru]

im laughing hysterically

[bloodSp3c]

the whole crafting/gathering system is a sham and needs to be scrapped!