Not sure if I'm doing it wrong, but this has me thoroughly stumped.

Im getting an error message: "You can sense something below..."

Now, in the past I basically understood this as, "the area is too high level for you to fish at." But I checked the area online, its level 55. Im using the correct sky bait, I have the trait that allows me to fish @ 55 holes... and also my Provision daily is asking for a fish that comes from a Hole that i cant fish at...

Is this a Bug, or am I doing something wrong?