Relic weapon.

[Merryl]

The whm relic is pretty. The rest of them I threw away to prevent any more wasted time.

[BushWookie]

Still prefer more crit and less mind than no crit. But I see your point though.

Why would you ever take crit over mind?

Crit is useless on a healer.

[Khyan]

Why would you ever take crit over mind?

Crit is useless on a healer.

You're right. Totally useless on a scholar. lol.

http://ffxiv.gamerescape.com/wiki/Adloquium

Of course mind is better since it's a major stat, but as a optional stat, crit is still the best option for scholar. Even more in HW with the new skills.

The scholar weapons from new dungeon aren't worth it (51 - 59 dungeons) if you have last resort zeta with full crit/det.
I changed my weapon only at level 60 even if I had all scholar books from new dungeon (51-59, not 60). My zeta was melded with accuracy/crit and det.

The crit nerf is essential, it's just an overall change for new stuff.