Quote Originally Posted by Wintersandman View Post
How is situational not useful? There are even fewer times where I would want to use the proposed changes to it.

PLD finally feels like it has a complete toolkit. Sheltron, and even Divine Veil were nice additions. Saved several groups with Clemency and RA/GB are no brainers.

Cover is just one of those tools in a toolkit. It's like saying Holmgang is not useful as again it is situational.
But Holmgang has a definitive purpose, that can be applied to a variety of circumstances in both pve and pvp. Cover in comparison is very niche in pvp, there aren't many if any times that one needs to use cover. In pvp cover is a must since healers are the primary target. In pve this type of circumstance rarely happens since the tank maintains control over mobs. Maybe it would be a bit more useful if it could also redirect magic damage as well.