Quote Originally Posted by Sidra View Post
4 person Dungeon - Whispering Dawn at pull. WD heals for the equivalent of 2 Physiks - which saved me 2 GCDs before I have to pup out of CS to heal. Thats 2 Broils, which is more than Selene's buff would have added to the pull. Next pull, Fey Illumination (Selene's would have been down) - that extra healing power saves me 1 GCD to heal - 1 Broil - Selene would have added nothing that pull.

That's why EOS is superior for 4 person dungeons, assuming the SCH is DPSing.
And this is the kind of thought process Scholar's should be employing when considering their fairy selection.

Likewise, if gear scores got to a point where Selene w/ Rouse could heal every pull without additional assistance, then you pick Selene and get the DPS boost while maintaining your normal DPS without missing a beat.