Content should be challenging to execute... Not challenging to learn

[Khalithar]

I'd be fine with going in blind in learning mechanics if they gave you some idea of what to do. For instance in A1, one of my party members ran through the add debuff and got shrunk, that's when we came up with the idea of putting it under the missiles, none of us had done the fight before.

While in A4 with the judgment debuff, it doesn't accurately explain what to do with it or what it does. That is what I'd call a bad way to do things, they shouldn't be stingy with information.

I really think this game needs a dungeon journal like WoW where it tells you what the boss mechanics are and what they do so you have some idea of what will happen when you go in. But just because you have an idea of what the mechanics are, you still need to figure out the specific strategy around the mechanics and practice until you know what they look like and what to watch out for.

Edit:

This is easy mode and alot of the mechanics are similar to coil.

Not everyone that plays the game ever did coil. I've already cleared Alexander, all four floors, and started the game about a month and a half ago at the end of may. I didn't have time to do coil as I was focused on Main Story Quests and getting my ilevel up before HW, I have no idea what any of the coil mechanics are, what the zones are like, or exactly what coil even is. It would be a better bet to assume that the people doing Alexander right now have never done coil.