If someone is talking a lot in a dungeon they get mine. Even if they are superbad.

Sometimes I give commendations to new players who after a few mitakes learn and improves.

Also as a healer I get far more commendations than I deserve. Im not sure how many times ive used regen only and then threw a stone or two and then jumped about for a bit. And still got 3 commendations.
Healing in this game is toi easy so I dont feel like i deserve them