Ok well I'm super biased for Mooncats because they're better than suncats I like the lore more, however... your two Seekers are very cute. I like them a lot (personally not a fan of the blueberry cats but hey, whatever).

Um. When I created my character I knew I was going to be archer/bard and I knew I was going to choose male Keeper. I actually get mistaken a lot for a Seeker because no one seems to realize you can have dark brown skin on a Keeper..haha. I'm also not a fan of plate armor.. I think only my PLD wears anything like that? Yeah.

My favorite is the second Seeker (yellow facepaint version). My second fav is the one you have now, the Xaela. I'd say go for either those ones.

Sorry that ain't much help. Happy choosing