In tanking stance (defiance/shield oath) WAR was a clear winner and will continue to be so. (PLD vs WAR only)

WAR has unchained and Innerbeast which ignore the penalty as well as Maim which negates a good chunk of is. (damage up 20%)
PLD has nothing to counter Shield oath.

The old order for DPS was.

PLD SwO MT + WAR OT
WAR MT + PLD SwO OT
WAR + WAR
PLD SwO + PLD SwO
WAR Def + PLD SwO OT
WAR def + WAR OT
PLD ShO + WAR OT
PLD ShO + PLD OT