This has been a very short, but sweet Cycle. We have seen a lot of new faces and old. And while I am sad my prediction did not come true, you three have all done great work. You 3 finalists have shown amazing growth and each of you was placed nr 1 or 2 at least once in my critiques. Here is my appraisal of your final submissions:
1) Nozomi Kei – This is something I have come accustomed to expect in ENTM. A picture that tells a story, in this case even without the blurb. It’s framed nicely with this over the shoulder view from the Roegadyn, though – and I hate to sound like our favourite Lala – I wish you were not centered. A bit further to the right maybe, because even though you are an Elezen you feel much dwarfed. Still, this is a great picture and my favourite of the Final Round.
2) Sunny Day – This reminds me a bit of Epsil’s shot from Round 1. Some improvement in the lighting and if we could see a bit more of your face and it’d be perfect. As it is still one hell of a picture. The downside however, while it is a great action shot… I cannot make out enough to really identify anything that makes this a fate and not a simple battle shot.
3) Stephen Fairbrook - Aww. You have done great shots, but this isn’t one of them. The framing is nice enough but it’s really just you next to a Kedtrap. It feels non interactive, a very simple posing shot. Compared to Nozomi and Sunny where they have either a story or some action, this is a bit of a let-down.
Now, since I need to give a final answer based on the entire portfolio, I decided to stay true to my decisions of past rounds because that always was written after careful deliberation and I will use those as measurements. I wrote myself a list where I wrote down your rankings per round and assigned 3, 2 or 1 points depending on who placed above the other two, in the middle and last.
I got the following results after tallying up 5 rounds:
Stephen Fairbrook 11
Sunny Day 8
Nozomi Kei 11
Really close there!With the Final Round added, my final ranking of you is thusly:
3rd Place: Sunny Day with 10 points
2nd Place: Stephen Fairbrook with 12 points
1st Place: Nozomi Kei with 14 points
As many have commented, you three were incredibly well matched and it was a close race. You all deserve praise! You came up with great ideas and compositions and I really only chose this system to determine my winner because I would not know how to otherwise. That’s how close this call is.
Nozomi, I hope you win, you deserve it. My favourite picture in your portfolio is still the Cosplay one. The beauty in its simplicity still blows me away. I hope you choose that one as your “Winner’s Picture” to be displayed if you win. :3

With the Final Round added, my final ranking of you is thusly:
Reply With Quote








