I like both Tank roles, (and DRK soon too I hope) but I prefer PLD over WAR simply because of the sheer number of defensive options PLDs have. Most people seem to only care about being aggressive and think damage and attacking is everything. They seem to forget that there are more calm people out there who'd rather take a different approach instead of just being as aggressive as possible. Plus, PLD's will be getting more options to work with in attacking anyway come Heavensward, so yay to that!

So... I disagree with you OP. I have more fun as a PLD then I do as a WAR~