When/Why did you vote kick?

[Geist]

Same as most people above: either because the party member in question ends up as unreachable (disconnected), or in the instance of somebody acting in questionable ways (aka, being a jerk / disrespectful / actively hostile and harmful) towards the rest of the party and other alliances.

Never a matter of skill, but of practicality and mutual respect.

[Linnaete]

Aside from the understandably mundane reasons, I enthusiastically had a trollish Dragoon kicked out of our World of Darkness alliance yesterday.

There were a couple of new folks in the raid and this guy was deliberately yelling out false instructions on how to handle boss mechanics. Angra Mainyu? Keep accumulating ireful or sullen stacks he said, and then stand in FRONT of the boss. That is the win button! Totes!

We got rid of him before the next boss. While we're sure the new folks were smart enough (or at least familiar enough with the basic strategy tips) to do the opposite of what the guy commanded them to do (and embarrassingly, he broadcasted these false instructions to the whole raid...), we were not risking it for the upcoming bosses, and nor were we standing for this moron.

Kicked him for trolling and for leeching. He admitted also that he was not going to bother with his rotations. He was just planning to auto-attack his way through the whole raid.