Hihi~ Since we didn't get to record judge's comments for Round 9-12, I thought I'd post my comments for Round 9-11 here.
Round 9
Doki - Love the peacefulness that your picture potrays, but a little empty on the right side though, perhaps a minion like a couerl kitten looking at you would help fill up the space.
Dragon Lily - Love the bard song effect, however the right side seems very cluttered with the flowers and the left side feels very empty.
Eldaena - I like the sparkly effects and how your pure white outfit stands out a lot. But your character looking behind with that expression seems a little off to me, as if she noticed she's being ambushed or something. Might be better if she's looking up towards the left side where the sun is.
Masha - Thumbs up to the concept of the picture! The color of your outfit is a little too matchy with your surroundings so it makes you blend into the surroundings instead of standing out in this picture. Love how the rocks adds dimension to the picture!
Mini Ninja - I really like the sun rays in your picture but it's a pity a part of it gets blocked off by the canopy!
Rina - Same thing as Masha, your outfit is too matchy in color, it feels like your character and the flower behind you are fighting for attention.
Twilight Dove - So much purpleeeeeee~ and yes once again, too matchy in color, your character is blending in with surroundings! The orange sylph lights are drawing away the attention from your character! Love the concept though! There isn't dead space in this picture so thumbs up to that!
Round 10
Doki - Love your playful expression while sitting on the throne! But the background of the house(wood ceiling & stone walls) doesn't match the crystal throne, yes I know nothing can be done to change the ceiling but it just doesn't match.
Dragon Lily - I like the concept of your picture, but I think it would be better if it's nightfall so the only light source would be the fire.
Eldaena - Major love to the sci-fi feel of your picture. The background of your picture is amazinggggggggg!!
Masha - Color coordination is great in this picture and the outfit gives all 3 of you a personality(big thumbs up)! I also like how your extras are looking at you, waiting for orders instead of looking elsewhere.
Rina - I usually love battle effects but in this picture, the battle effects kinda ruined it. And your extras feel like they're not thereThe Garuda stands out more than you and your extras.
Twilight Dove - Love love love how all the attention is drawn to you because of the light and because of the color of the outfit, the extra in the middle didn't get lost in the picture even without a "spotlight".
Round 11
Doki - Concept of a night party is great! But your character seems a little bit too far away from the party and its a little funny to see your character all lit up without knowing where the source of the light is coming from.
Dragon Lily - The weather looks really good for a day at the beach! But the rock, the ship, and the tower feels like they're stickers you would stick on in an activity book, makes the picture feel a little weird.
Eldaena - Be careful where you spray the champagne Eldaena! Love this picture a lot, it feels so romantic!! IIRC I ranked this top 3. I just love the overall feel that your picture gives and there's no dead space at all.
Masha - Same thing as Dragon Lily! The ship and the tower look like stickers >_<! I like the sun ray and the effects of the water splashing under your feet though!
Twilight Dove - Your picture just screams FUN all over!! I like there's different layers in your picture, doesn't feel flat to me at all. I like how you have a extra cheering you from behind, just adds more to the fun element!