Is this the repair system players' wanted?

[ObeiKinstar]

Good Morning

Dark Matter to replace ALL repair mats, seems a little generic to me. I understand the inconvenience of having different repair materials clogging up inventory space. I understand the inconvenience of having to find someone with repair mats or having to locate them yourself.

I understand that the repair system isn't convenient! It's not supposed to be!

Repairing things takes time, and it should be that way. If you go out into battle and spend a decent amount of time in the field you are likely to damage your weapon. It takes a while to break a weapon with our current system if you are using a rank appropriate weapon. I don't feel the time it takes to break a weapon or to repair it is inappropriate at all.

Limited amounts of space is an issue that plagues everyone irl or in-game. I keep a few inventory spaces on my retainer to hold my most used and most rare repair mats. When going into battle I throw my weapon repair mats in my bazaar. (I usually dont even need it before I get back into town, but just in case)

It takes time to go to the MW and find your repair mats, or to shout out for an item to be repaired. However I have never found it to take an inappropriate amount of time.

For me removing the repair items and replacing them with dark matter seems very generic and makes me lose some interest in the game. I disagree with the decision to do this and hope that they will change it back.

Some ides that I feel would have been better would be to have the repair npc move into a repair store. ( there are planty of places already in game that would work perfectly in each town) Have them sell all repair materials for marked up prices. (this would help to create a gil sink but not hurt the gatherers ability to profit off repair mats. That way if an item wasnt found in the wards you always have the option to instant buy for just a bit more) Finally have the repair npc repair to 100%. Then you could have the old repair npc still repair to 75% for a smaller amount of gil as they are apprentices.

What do you think?

[ObeiKinstar]

Like if you Do Not like Dark Matter idea.

[Feldt]

A little offtopic from Me ^^

Like if you Do Not like Dark Matter idea.

Like if you like and want Dark Matter system

Like if you don't care as long as it's less of a pain than the current system.

EDIT: I can't like my own posts, shoot.

Like if you're of two minds and simply want to see how it plays out.

Like It if you think peaople are using this kind of a pool system only to get more medals on forums

(dang To bad I can't vode since I would liked this... IMHO since we have medals for likes then people shouldnt do this kind of farmlikage since they only gaining tons of medals they shouldn't have.)

oh and just noticed:

Like if you hate people farming likes with dumb polls like this.

[ObeiKinstar]

Like if you like and want Dark Matter system

[SuzakuCMX]

Like if you don't care as long as it's less of a pain than the current system.

EDIT: I can't like my own posts, shoot.

[Catapult]

Like if you're of two minds and simply want to see how it plays out.

[Malakhim]

I appreciate the game for taking a more realistic approach to crafting(seriously, look up tanning and goldsmithing... FFXIV is surprisingly accurate), but at the same time, we ARE playing a game, and I feel that the repair system in the game still needs some work and by simplifying the process even by a bit I think it becomes more about fun and less "ugh."

Now I haven't been playing recently so I don't know what the situation is currently, but I feel that there aren't even tangible reasons to keep your gear up to spec in the first place. Since the introduction of static SP, you'll gain the same amount of SP regardless of any gear damage, and(as far as I've noticed), you don't even get a damage reduction to your weapons or reduced damage resistance on your armor when they're all damaged.

In short, I feel that adding some sort of "mysterious panacea" for gear repair is great, but to me at least repairing still needs work.

Keep in mind as well that we can always just give feedback and ask them to get rid of it if it ends up sucking.

[Alcide]

If they're nerfing the repair system so much why don't they just get rid of it? >.>

[Anty]

If they're nerfing the repair system so much why don't they just get rid of it? >.>

true, they should just get rid of it or make more reasonable prizes at repair npcs and let them repair to 100%.
The way it will be now is again one of these "bug-fix" like changes and doesn't feel like an overhaul at least not a thoughtful one.

[Biggs]

If they're nerfing the repair system so much why don't they just get rid of it? >.>

Because repairs will be directly linked to dying penalities now. Each time you die and return without a raise, you take a quality hit on all your gear. This is meant to give death signifigance and encourage others to use raise. I think this is just a portion of change to the repair system that is leading to something bigger and we should hold judgment until 1.19 when they do the crafting overhauls.