After failing to reclaim on my artisan off hand crafts 2 out of 3 times..That was it..
After that, I worked on my rotation so I rarely ever need to reclaim.. and if I have to I'll just hit Byregots without a steady hand instead and go for the finisher..
Worked out good for me, only failed one craft since then so far and that was because I forgot to put in all the cross class skills..