Quote Originally Posted by Saseal View Post
How about this - At the end, a window showing lvl/ilvl and your healing/DPS/Defensive scores (based on your job, or not) - and then comparing to the dungeon/trial/raid's average (collected from scores of other random players of similar level - or ilvl if it's level 50 content - that have gone through the dungeon over the past x days) for your role - AND only shown to you, about you. You then have something to compare it to so you can see if you're doing average (and those that don't want to be average can start looking into adjusting their rotation/hunting for info or advice), below average (and again look to better yourself) or above average - in which case, 'good jeorbs'.
I figured 'averages' for dungeons so that it's not directly comparing yourself to the other party members, but rather a % of players - to avoid some of the issues people were stating earlier (player harassment, etc).

Or, if you REALLY wanted comparisons within the party, perhaps bring up the screen AFTER the duty is over (I guess this would only work in DF and not in PF since there would be no anonymity after the run ends in PF) so the people can see the numbers, but not be harassed or do any harassing (or low chance of it). If they want to better themselves, that's still a conscious thought and drive they would have to have regardless if they saw the stats with or without the rest of the party there. People that don't want to just won't, regardless the advice or information given.
This is what I'd like to see, albeit with less noble intentions. To me, comparing yourself to just the party is too small a scope. Not to mention it wouldn't really give you anything substantial unless you run with the same party all the time. Some runs you might be 3rd highest, other runs you might be 1st without changing anything. Would that encourage you? Not saying it doesn't have its own merit, just that I'd like to think...bigger.