ICANN what? Ugh. Do you know the phrase whack-a-mole? It's a game that's being played with The Pirate Bay, that infamous torrent site. The cops raid it, shut it down, and it pops up again somewhere else, then the cops virtual raid it, get it shut down, then it pops up somewhere else. So even if ICANN or someone else closed the site down, it can still popup elsewhere. Technically speaking, unless gil selling sites are intentionally taking payments and not delivering the product/service they have promised to, they aren't a scam site. If they are infected with malware, they sometimes (usually through users reporting it) get blocked or give a malware warning when you go to those sites. And despite what some people here clearly think, gil selling is not illegal, and no, it's not "unethical" except to those few of you that for whatever reason have decided it's against your personal views.