PVP is dead on FFXIV. It`s very disappointing as I find a lot of replay value in an MMORPG comes from PVP.

My suggestion:

1. Eliminate GC vs GC vs GC pvp.

2. Create smaller sized pvp battlegrounds.

3. Create a third type off disciples, specifically used for PVP. These disciples could have stats, build, equipment and abilities specifically balanced for PVP.

4. Add open world objectives accessible only as this new disciples class. Allow PVP between these new disciples classes freely and openly in the world.

5. Exclude disciples of war and disciples of the hand to participate in PVP either in battlegrounds or open world.