Quote Originally Posted by Soukyuu View Post
Because too many people end up dragging sliders to random directions trying to outdo each other by making the characters as ugly as possible. Or, if the system allows it even abuse it, try selecting a character that is 1 pixel wide everywhere :P
Best system would be one that allows sliders but limit them to realistic proportions, imho.

The discussion is starting to repeat itself btw, we had most arguments and counterarguments for the systems a la Aion/PW already.
This is why the Phantasy Star Universe-esque slider would be good. It allows for good diverse body types, but it also prevents you from being able to create the oddly shaped extremes you can in games such as Aion.