Thread: Specialist System in 3.0

Originally Posted by scarebearz

I was only talking about the tokens to be honest, as those need to be unlocked in the first place.

To reliably HQ those I do think PbP and Byregot's are essential. (along with sh2 and some l15 ones ofc)

For 3 and 4* normal crafts, as long as you have sh2 and l15 skills, i'm fairly sure I'd have a decent HQ rate without any l50 skills, if starting with all HQ mats. GS>AT with 10/11 stacks is quite effective if I remember correctly.

I just tested making the Reinforced Spruce Plywood HQ, got it on 2nd attempt. Used level 15 and 37 cross class skills. All progress came from RS & SS, finished was 11 stacks, GS, Good condition and BB. 87% HQ chance. The first attempt only failed because i wasn't sure how much progress i would get from Basic Synth and Standard Synth, i ran out of steps and didn't get enough progress to finish the synt. Overall took 7 progress steps with 453 craftmanship. It was harder to drop my craftmanship from 495 to 453 than to make an HQ token mat lol ^^

Originally Posted by scarebearz

Though I'd put this to the test and it was dead easy to HQ a 4* craft, using no level 50 skills, when starting with all HQ mats.

Nice to see you tested it as well, i tested it myself first before i had posted it on the forum. I didn't use all hq mats, i had about 1200-1400 starting quality depending on the synth and i finished with GS + BB, but AT would have probably worked as well, can't say for sure.

Edit: All of this testing reminds me of day 4 star release. Makes me wonder what the craftsmanhip needed to do 3 star in 4 progress steps.

Originally Posted by Lemuria

That would depend on your actual stats though. If you've got some insanely well melded artisan gear and Lucis tools, you're going to have an easier time than someone who's at entry level for 4-star crafts. Even with full HQ materials, some struggle to get a HQ result on 4-star.

Also, does that lack of level 50 skills also mean no Careful Synthesis II? That means each synthesis either has a chance of failure, or a lower efficiency rate. Or both. Careful synthesis is only 90% efficiency, while basic and standard synthesis come with a 10% failure rate. Seems like a heavy burden to place yourself into. And no Piece by Piece to speed things up either.

To be honest, if people are struggling to HQ with All HQ Mats and level 50 skills, they are crafting very badly. Lucis actually makes very little difference, the min stats needed for 4* are already very high.

I used SH2 + RS for most of the progress and finished using CS (lvl15 version).

Haven't read the entire thread, but I'll put in my two cents that as a casual crafter the idea of specialization highly appeals to me.

I understand that the armory system encourages diversification, like on combat classes, but combat classes require only a couple jobs at a moderate level. It encourages the player to branch out and dabble, but not master. The current crafting system demands that every DoH be fully capable at everything. You may as well merge them into a single job that can do everything, and this, I feel, defeats the purpose of a system that encourages you to switch between roles.

I'm fine with dedicated crafters being able to tackle all crafts, just as dedicated raiders can opt to level and gear every combat job. But I would be a lot more interested in crafting if allowed to work at a capable level in a handful of crafts.

Originally Posted by scarebearz

To be honest, if people are struggling to HQ with All HQ Mats and level 50 skills, they are crafting very badly. Lucis actually makes very little difference, the min stats needed for 4* are already very high.

I used SH2 + RS for most of the progress and finished using CS (lvl15 version).

Necro!!! You mean to tell me that the lucis tool isn't glamor??? and serves an "actual" purpose??? =D

Having said that, lucis is unnecessary and meant for casuals not hardcore crafters. Why do i say this?

1) Meant to allow for unmelded offhand
2) All the mats come from leve's and GC trade in.

It adds absolutely nothing when it comes to progress quality.

Oh but the extra craftsmanship!!! Well if you already have 453 before lucis, then seeing as you don't save a step it's pointless.
Oh but the extra control!!! Well if you couldn't HQ without the additional 16 control, then it sure won't make much of a difference anyways.

Personally i like my luminaries more than my lucis =D

---

Back on topic tho, i have so many questions how leveling is going to work from 50-60 because they have to cater to both new and old crafters. I'm more interested in what we're going to use in terms of mats. A hardcore crafter will be able to 50-55 in every class within 12-18 hours i think and 55-60 within 6 hours. Assuming that they don't care about price of new mats. I can easily see the race for 8x60 being less 24 hours long.

Just some stats for people. It's about 88 crafts for every 5 level, regardless of if it's 15-20 or 40-45. I don't expect that to change.

Originally Posted by dspguy

Very true. Same as how supra made no difference back when 3-star was the highest craft. The control bonus is nice. But in scheme of things, very small. Sure, there is that sweet spot where a cumulative gain of 100-150 quality over 10-11 IQ stacks from that tiny control increase on the lucis, will make the difference between a 30% HQ and 50% HQ chance. Outside of that, lucis is all about backworn e-peen crafting tools.

Types of crafters:
--------------------
1) Had melded offhand to 453 before apron was released. Got lucis and apron. Not going to bother remelding offhand, capped at 427 control.

2) Didn't meld off hand at all, got lucis, doesn't have a reason to meld offhand now. 424 control.

3) Maxed control at 440 just because.

Also, as long as you hit 11 stacks, which should be always. You won't get into the sweet spot.