Personally Physical level is fairly easy to obtain and doesnt have a main purpose right now. Most of the traits such as Dex, Str, Int, Pie dont have much of an effect. I would be for either completely fixing the current system and make caps for each class this way there is a little bit more job uniqueness with the addition of being able to set up how you want your points allocated saved automatically for each job class, or completely wipe out that system and bring in more of a system that FFXI used. This way it will still benefit the players that are more dedicated and job classes will get more of a specialized niche.

And to help ease the feeling of losing progress if the current system is scrapped and a new system for example like FFXI was in place. If SE allowed everyone to be capped on all attributes for your rank, would that change your minds. We all know that one day the top rank from 50 to whatever will increase and basically if you have a rank 50 job already most likely you will also have capped out your physical level. So it would be more like a swap from one system to another. Nothing was lost and you only have more to gain in the process.