Just for fun: Tank archetypes!

[TruebladeNuke]

Tanks that pull 3 packs at once when any of the following are true:
2) Their DPS are both MNK

I had a case like this in reverse order. I was Tanking a dungeon, both DPS were Monks, so I figured AoE power was more or less non-existent, and thus I made smaller pulls then I usually do. (Because you know, MNK's were designed more or less to pick out a single target and demolish that said target) Said WHM goes and runs off pulling all groups I haven't pulled with Aero's and runs back to us with HUGE mobs following him/her. I pull all hate for the sake of not allowing the Healer to die, but the MNK's made it quite known they didn't like that. WHM just scoffs, saying pulling all mobs is required, period, due to gear levels. Nevermind the fact that both DPS are Monks...

Got through just fine though, since I know what I'm doing as a Tank and WHM knew what to do as WHM. Did take awhile to fully destroy any large trash mob due to lack of AoE power, save the WHM.

Said scenario could have easily classified as a "WTFWHM" scenario, if it weren't for dem pro heals.

[Lovemonster]

I wonder why monks wouldn't like it though. They keep their G3 rather than lose it between each pull since no tank staggers their pulls these days and WHM gets to Holy which means a faster dungeon in general.

[TruebladeNuke]

I wonder why monks wouldn't like it though. They keep their G3 rather than lose it between each pull since no tank staggers their pulls these days and WHM gets to Holy which means a faster dungeon in general.

Depends on who you end up running with mostly.

While those Monks made it known that due to their class, AoE power was lacking, others MNK's I've worked with don't complain. It's more or less that like I said in my earlier post, Monks were designed to pick out a single target and quickly destroy that target. AoE isn't their thing. (And it was obvious during the pulls of that run I made. It took longer to bring down the mobs than say... if I had 2 BLM's with me) Most players playing as a MNK understand that too. If it really comes down to the Monk needing to spam AoE, (and most that I've seen go for this anyway, lol) the best they can do is use the "Perfect Balance" buff and then spam Rockbreaker... which only lasts for 10 seconds. (And then they have to wait for the cooldown) Bonus points to them if they pop damage buffs before Perfect Balance. Oh, and line themselves to toss out a Howling Fist, which is a free CD skill use.

Because of the way the MNK is designed, this means that WHM's have to worry about their MP management even more if they're going to Cleric Stance Holy, even with Shroud of Saints MP management. (Cause Holy is expensive per cast) SCH's not so much, despite not having Holy to spam.

I'd also say it depends on the dungeon too. I could see fully beefed out teams of 2 MNK DPS getting away with bigger pulls on the lower/beginner High Level dungeons, like Wanderer's Palace. (Like how I managed to get through just fine anyway in that one run) But the higher up dungeons where the enemies take more hits to bring down and hit harder? Becomes debatable then. Down to how well your party members dodge things and such. I can't really give a full "correct" answer here, as every person is different in how they want to approach a dungeon, regardless of party setup. Me? I just try to adapt as best I can, and hope the others do the same.

tl;dr: Depends on the party, dungeon, etc.