. . . wearing ilvl55 gear (lol 3,000 HP == Food)

. . . ignoring party instruction?

Where do you draw the line?

Should FFXIV even have such a bar? (I don't play other MMOs so I don't know how those work either)

I come from a competitive Total War and Battlefield background, kicking is standard procedure, you don't win unless you trim the fat (and they don't learn to play until you give them the boot).

Granted in BF they are only removed from squad, not the match entirely. TW though is a different story, losing your clan is like losing your ability to play.

. . . Where does SE stand on this?

. . . /SeanConneryVoice: "What are you prepared to do!?"