I have been taking a break from tanking recently, and I have this bad habit of trying to profile people according to the race they choose - a bad habit indeed. But one thing I have always noticed is that Roegadyn tanks will never let you down. I have not ever really seen a bad roe tank, honestly. Though if I had any complaints about any of them it would be their occasional arrogance but their flawless tanking makes it kind of justified, in my opinion.

The worse roe tank I had was a lv.40 PLD without shield oath, and didn't really know at first that pulling the aevis away from the mobs was essential for clearing the trash in Stone Vigil, but he was willing to learn and listen to everyone giving him useful advice and eventually understood how to pull properly. So thank you Roegadyn players for being such stereotypically good tanks!

Hyur tanks on the other hand... well, don't get me started.