When I was in Alliance A, our tank pulled the Eye boss and held it even as the other alliance tanks asked "who's MT?" (i.e. is A MTing? because B usually MTs). Our tank DID NOT have ANY Oath buff on. We, in his party, told him to put Oath on (even Sword Oath!) but he ignored us. It was very hard for the healers to keep up with the damage that he took, and in the end he died... and then he RAISED outside of battle. Our alliances were Japanese, and that English-speaking tank wrote in very bad Japanese that "IF YOU'RE BOTH READY I DON'T FEEL THE NEED TO SAY MY ALLIANCE IS READY". We vote kicked him and thankfully he did not get back in. While what he said was true if he was supposed to be MT, in that instance he was very wrong: 1) Paladin with no Oath despite being told to put Oath on; 2) pulled the boss even though he did not state that he would MT; 3) raised out of battle when he was MT.

I totally feel you. I can only hope that Vote Kick would actually keep the KICKED people OUT.