PLD Novus: Parry or DET?

[Martin_Arcainess]

I've already got my Novus and close to Nexus but I was wondering about the stats I put in. I enjoy endgame content and wish to perform at my best for it. I've put Acc as my main stat and Parry as my 2nd main. I had a discussion about it and 2 people said to me Parry is a shit Stat and that it should be DET over Parry any any.

Which is a more better stat for PLD to have? DET or Parry? Or doesn't it really matter? If you think either one of them then please in detail explain why you think so but also let's keep in mind for some people if their happy with Parry or DET let's keep that way and not start a flame war trying to insult the other person for going with that stat.


My reason for Parry was due to mitigation it gives me on Physical attacks but now I'm told T13 has alot of Magic based attacks.

[SirTaint]

DET is far superior to Parry. DET is always useful, parry is rarely useful. 3.3 DET = 1 STR. You also get the full stat bonus as you upgrade by capped Det and one other stat.

When people are pushing content under geared parry can be useful for progression. At this point in 2.5 is already useless.

[Donjo]

DET is far superior to Parry. DET is always useful, parry is rarely useful. 3.3 DET = 1 STR. You also get the full stat bonus as you upgrade by capped Det and one other stat.

When people are pushing content under geared parry can be useful for progression. At this point in 2.5 is already useless.

Unless the "full bonus" is having more than 59 stat points on the sword, then I got it with Accuracy and Parry. As for the Shield... yeah, that one's dumb to get any bonus on.

But to the OP: Accuracy was a good first stat to put on. Accuracy's always a good idea to have on a weapon. It is far better to be over cap than under cap, especially for a Tank. As for DET vs. Parry, I'll say the same thing I always say: the game is constructed such that secondary stats barely matter so that people may choose whatever they want and not magically become useless to their party. So, all you need to do is answer this question: do you want to do a little more damage or do you want a little more mitigation?

[Martin_Arcainess]

Thank you both for your answers.

@Donjo yeah with Acc capped I'm a bit more free to do what I want with gear and Parry Vs DET don't bother me that much but the people who I seemed to have the discussion with made it seemed like you have Parry your shit.

@Sirtaint I always find parry to be handy for Physical attacks. Don't suppose you can go into more detail as to why it's more useful?

[Donjo]

Thank you both for your answers.

@Donjo yeah with Acc capped I'm a bit more free to do what I want with gear and Parry Vs DET don't bother me that much but the people who I seemed to have the discussion with made it seemed like you have Parry your shit.

@Sirtaint I always find parry to be handy for Physical attacks. Don't suppose you can go into more detail as to why it's more useful?

I'm currently trying to fight the entire notion that any Secondary Stat is "wasted" or "shit", because they're largely superfluous and have actually become less relevant with each iLvl jump.

I can also speak for Sir Taint as to why Det is "always useful". The gist of the matter is that something that adds damage to your attacks will always apply no matter what you're doing with it. Whether you're actively tanking an enemy or not, you'll be dealing more damage. Parry, conversely, has two major situations where it does nothing for you at all: if you're being attacked by magic and if you aren't tanking something. Thus, it can be said that Determination is more useful because it's always doing something to help you.

[Lavieh]

I'm currently trying to fight the entire notion that any Secondary Stat is "wasted" or "shit", because they're largely superfluous and have actually become less relevant with each iLvl jump.

The ilvl jump has played no impact on useful secondary stats are. Also, Secondary stats are incredibly powerful if min/maxed properly.

[Donjo]

The ilvl jump has played no impact on useful secondary stats are. Also, Secondary stats are incredibly powerful if min/maxed properly.

I shall discuss this further in another thread, but this is false. Furthermore, there are only two situations in which min maxing the secondaries for damage actually has a significant effect(and by significant, I mean more than a 1-2% difference in effective main stat): Summoners, and a Tank moving from pure Parry to pure Damage.

[Lavieh]

I shall discuss this further in another thread, but this is false. Furthermore, there are only two situations in which min maxing the secondaries for damage actually has a significant effect(and by significant, I mean more than a 1-2% difference in effective main stat): Summoners, and a Tank moving from pure Parry to pure Damage.

BRD and Ninja can both get almost 1 Weapon damage by using i110 crafted pieces in their Best in slot as opposed to their i130 counterparts. Secondary stats do make a huge difference.

Both on paper and personal experience will tell you this is true.

[Izsha]

I enjoy endgame content and wish to perform at my best for it.
....
Which is a more better stat for PLD to have?

He asked for what's better). Not " which stats are within a range of decent to good". Just because secondary skills don't make up 80% of you damage doesn't change the fact that it's worse. 2% less is still not better. How much a stat has to improve you to be "good" or "significant" or "huge" or "worth the gil" is subjective. I may think 2% is very significant, you may not. Subjective.

Better is not subjective. Det is better.

Accuracy, while helpful I prefer to use for crit as accuracy is only relevant in current endgame. I want a weapon I spend time and millions on to aid me in everything from a roulette dungeon up to t13, but some people prefer to min max hard line for coil and accuracy can work for that if you build your weapon to match your gear, but gear changes and so has coil 3x now so I don't bother with acc. If you shape your weapon around your gear and coil then acc can be bis. If you shape it as a general weapon then do crit for 2nd stat. Always useful, never wasted in any content.

[Ashkendor]

I melded mine Acc/Parry because it was cheap and at least somewhat useful. I'm going to go back and respec it for Acc/Det/Crit (I see no reason to max out Acc with tank gear having so much) since I have more $$ to throw at it.